Image

Journalists are horrified judges disagree with their biased legal opinions

In a salient display of a free press and journalistic independence, the Australian government-owned national broadcaster has taken the Australian government’s Federal Police to court to block them reading documents seized when officers executed a search warrant. Who grants search warrants? Is it the Prime Minister, any elected official or bureaucrat in their employ? No.…

In a salient display of a free press and journalistic independence, the Australian government-owned national broadcaster has taken the Australian government’s Federal Police to court to block them reading documents seized when officers executed a search warrant.

Who grants search warrants? Is it the Prime Minister, any elected official or bureaucrat in their employ? No. It’s a judge, or a trusted and accountable registrar with their delegated power who Federal Police had to persuade of the merits of their application for the warrant to search.

Australian and international media have howled with indignant outrage at the notion they and their sources are accountable to “onerous” national secrecy laws. All of their commentaries is largely one-sided and entirely self-serving. No consumer of news should put any more weight in their opinions on this matter than in the opinion of outlaw bikies on anti-association laws. They are impossibly biased, and a more objective analysis is required.

As I opened, if accusations of a police-state dictatorship were credible their legal challenge would never have been permitted. Now that judicial authority has not only granted the original warrant but also upheld the appropriateness of the properly authorised and executed a search and its fruit, cries of “foul” are merely the boy crying “wolf”.

There is nothing to see here except an elite tantrum by the unrivalled voice of mainstream media collective agreement. The ABC and other whining journalists defaming the Federal Police investigation as nothing more than “an attempt to intimidate journalists for doing their job” are following an old legal saying.

When the facts are on your side, pound the facts. When the law is on your side, pound the law. When neither is on your side, pound the table.

The judiciary is separated from the government and law enforcement. They don’t actually get together over drinks in darkened rooms with upturned trench coat collars and decide on outcomes. I find it hard to believe this entire saga is a far-reaching conspiracy between the Federal Government, the Australian Federal Police, and the federal judiciary with an objective to protect Scott Morrison’s popularity polls.

The table-pounding claims about the public’s “right to know” has not been circumvented and no journalist has been criminalised.

According to the USA’s institutional leftists, a “whistleblower” is a long term Democrat activist trying to politically damage an incumbent right-wing government.

This stoush between journo’s and the AFP is merely an old-fashioned legal disagreement where one party emotionally claims their source is a “whistleblower” to be venerated and the other party claims the source was an illegal leak of classified Defence papers to be prosecuted. The legal system is how the dispute is settled, and it’s not unprecedented for the loser to blame the referee.

The objective observer can decide for themselves if the national broadcaster is pounding the facts, the law or the table.

What's New?

Use the blue arrows at the bottom to scroll through the latest.
The Ship of Theseus: What Is National Identity?

The Ship of Theseus: What Is National Identity?

"If a country's defining people group is gradually replaced over time—whether through migration, demographic shifts, or other means—in what sense is it still the same nation?"
By
by Staff WriterFeb 23, 2025
Our Civilisation Is at the Crossroads

Our Civilisation Is at the Crossroads

"We’ve told them that we don’t really have anything very great, or if we do we ought not to talk about it much. I believe this is wrong because what we have in the cities of Europe and the West are the greatest civilisation the world has known."
By
by Bill MuehlenbergFeb 22, 2025
Hungary Condemns the Murder of 70 Christians in Congo as the World Stays Silent

Hungary Condemns the Murder of 70 Christians in Congo as the World Stays Silent

"Hungary is the first, and only country to immediately condemn the latest massacre of Christians in the Congo."
By
by Rod LampardFeb 22, 2025
Australia’s US Alliance “Under Threat,” Warns Craig Kelly

Australia’s US Alliance “Under Threat,” Warns Craig Kelly

"Friendship is based on shared values... You don't have shared values if you're so afraid of your own people that you silence them and shut them up," Vance said.
By
by Staff WriterFeb 21, 2025
Vance Says Christianity Shapes His Politics: The Heart of Christianity Is Christ’s Resurrection

Vance Says Christianity Shapes His Politics: The Heart of Christianity Is Christ’s Resurrection

"The fundamental tenet of our faith is that the Son of God became man. He died and then he raised himself from the dead," the Vice President said.
By
by Staff WriterFeb 21, 2025
Words Matter

Words Matter

"Words matter. Ideas matter. Ideologies matter."
By
by Dr Stephen FysonFeb 21, 2025
Senator Gerard Rennick Announces New People First Party, Calls Out Hate Speech Overreach

Senator Gerard Rennick Announces New People First Party, Calls Out Hate Speech Overreach

"Let the facts make the case! Labor and the Liberal National Coalition are introducing laws that prevent free speech in this country."
By
by Rod LampardFeb 20, 2025

Image

Support

If you value our work and would like to support us, you can do so by visiting our support page. Can’t find what you’re looking for? Visit our search page.

Copyright © 2024, Caldron Pool

Permissions

Everything published at Caldron Pool is protected by copyright and cannot be used and/or duplicated without prior written permission. Links and excerpts with full attribution are permitted. Published articles represent the opinions of the author and may not reflect the views of all contributors at Caldron Pool.