Image

“Debate Is Hate” De Moraes Lifts Brazil’s X Ban

"He’s only now agreeing to lift the blockade after the elections are over."

Justice Alexandre De Moraes announced the reversal of Brazil’s X ban on Tuesday.

In a decision published online, De Moraes ramped up his war on what he called anti-democratic “digital militias.”

Presumably talking about Elon Musk, De Moraes’ initial ban blamed “extremist digital populists” using social media networks to spread “hate speech, and anti-democratic messages.”

The 8-page announcement restated justifications for his August ban on the social media platform.

Notably, De Moraes’ original decision repeated globalist leftwing propaganda, labelling dissent as “disinformation.”

“Use of disinformation,” the 8-page release form declared, “erodes the pillars of Democracy, and the rule of the law.”

The government, his ruling declared, demands “absolute respect,” and compliance with “the decisions of the Government judiciary.”

In other words, total compliance with what De Moraes demands and/or decides.

Point 1 of 8 made free speech the equivalent of violence, with De Moraes warning, that “freedom of expression should not be confused with freedom of aggression.”

Without defining the terms, De Moraes called bans on “hate speech and incitement necessary,” and then declared censorship constitutional.

Point 2 reasserted De Moraes’ dominion over “private entities” doing business in Brazil.

Stating the obvious, he reasoned that they should “respect the national legal system, and comply with direct commands issued by the Brazilian judiciary [i.e.: De Moraes].”

Points 3 and 4 discussed in-country representation, where the entity is within reach of the government; and physically accessible, making X more accountable to Brazilian law, and the judiciary’s direct commands.

Points 5 through 6, discussed civil liability, and X Brazil’s compliance with the direct commands of the judiciary.

Point 7 scolded X for “ostentatious and aggressive disrespect” towards the “judicial orders of the Brazilian judiciary.”

Subpoints here included Elon Musk pulling staff out of the country, and out of De Moraes’ reach.

This was accompanied by X having no legal representatives, and Musk not paying De Moraes’ fines.

Point 7 also gave special mention to “numerous offensive posts reiterating contempt” for the Brazilian “justice.”

Point 8 of 9 accused X of deliberate “non-compliance in order to establish an environment of total impunity and lawlessness on Brazilian social networks.”

Charging X with election interference, De Moraes added, X Brazil was aiding and abetting extremists “during the 2024 municipal elections.”

To this, he said, “X maintained and expanded itself as an instrument for digital militias, disseminating Nazi, racist, fascist, hateful, and anti-democratic speeches.”

Point 9 referred to the fiat banning X until a legal representative was appointed, and Musk paid what was effectively a free speech tax, in the form of a fine.

X challenged the ban, stating the company had complied with Brazilian law and De Moraes’ demands.

In September, X acquired a legal proxy.

On October 4, X then paid USD $5.2 million (28 million Brazilian Real) in fines.

Ending X’s ban, Brazil’s Attorney General said, X blocking profiles for “spreading false information,” paying fines, and appointing a proxy, meant “there was no reason to prevent the company from resuming its activities.

“The initial reasons for the ban no longer stand.”

Consequently, De Moraes “decreed the termination of X’s suspension,” then ordered telecommunications companies to comply.

Alliance Defending Freedom International (ADF) said they won’t be backing down.

De Moraes still needs to be held to account for banning X.

“He’s only now agreeing to lift the blockade after the elections are over.

“Censorship has been a persistent and escalating problem in Brazil since 2019,” ADF’s Director for Latin America explained.

“We will continue to make the case that the actions of De Moraes and the greater climate of censorship are unacceptable, until the day that freedom of expression and information are once again secured for all in Brazil.”

Dubbed dictator De Moraes, the justice stopped short of declaring victory in what appears to have been a convenient political exercise.

He admits that the 39-day war on Musk was motivated by local elections.

Hinting at the X ban being about “saving democracy,” De Moraes effectively said he killed free speech, in order to save democracy.

Given the context, the decision’s content suggests a completely different story: De Moraes killed freedom of speech in order to save Brazil’s Leftwing bureaucracy.

What's New?

Use the blue arrows at the bottom to scroll through the latest.
The Ship of Theseus: What Is National Identity?

The Ship of Theseus: What Is National Identity?

"If a country's defining people group is gradually replaced over time—whether through migration, demographic shifts, or other means—in what sense is it still the same nation?"
By
by Staff WriterFeb 23, 2025
Our Civilisation Is at the Crossroads

Our Civilisation Is at the Crossroads

"We’ve told them that we don’t really have anything very great, or if we do we ought not to talk about it much. I believe this is wrong because what we have in the cities of Europe and the West are the greatest civilisation the world has known."
By
by Bill MuehlenbergFeb 22, 2025
Hungary Condemns the Murder of 70 Christians in Congo as the World Stays Silent

Hungary Condemns the Murder of 70 Christians in Congo as the World Stays Silent

"Hungary is the first, and only country to immediately condemn the latest massacre of Christians in the Congo."
By
by Rod LampardFeb 22, 2025
Australia’s US Alliance “Under Threat,” Warns Craig Kelly

Australia’s US Alliance “Under Threat,” Warns Craig Kelly

"Friendship is based on shared values... You don't have shared values if you're so afraid of your own people that you silence them and shut them up," Vance said.
By
by Staff WriterFeb 21, 2025
Vance Says Christianity Shapes His Politics: The Heart of Christianity Is Christ’s Resurrection

Vance Says Christianity Shapes His Politics: The Heart of Christianity Is Christ’s Resurrection

"The fundamental tenet of our faith is that the Son of God became man. He died and then he raised himself from the dead," the Vice President said.
By
by Staff WriterFeb 21, 2025
Words Matter

Words Matter

"Words matter. Ideas matter. Ideologies matter."
By
by Dr Stephen FysonFeb 21, 2025
Senator Gerard Rennick Announces New People First Party, Calls Out Hate Speech Overreach

Senator Gerard Rennick Announces New People First Party, Calls Out Hate Speech Overreach

"Let the facts make the case! Labor and the Liberal National Coalition are introducing laws that prevent free speech in this country."
By
by Rod LampardFeb 20, 2025

Image

Support

If you value our work and would like to support us, you can do so by visiting our support page. Can’t find what you’re looking for? Visit our search page.

Copyright © 2024, Caldron Pool

Permissions

Everything published at Caldron Pool is protected by copyright and cannot be used and/or duplicated without prior written permission. Links and excerpts with full attribution are permitted. Published articles represent the opinions of the author and may not reflect the views of all contributors at Caldron Pool.