Image

Judge Rules Teachers Must ‘Celebrate’ Transgender Students

"In his judgment, Pepperall said that teachers must use compelled speech and 'respect and celebrate the pupil's personal autonomy,' regardless of the teacher's religious or philosophical beliefs."

A High Court judge in the UK has ruled that Christian teachers must ‘celebrate’ transgender students, upholding a ban on educators who will not use a pupil’s preferred pronouns.

According to Christian Concern, Mr Justice Pepperall ruled last week that Christian maths teacher, Joshua Sutcliffe, should continue to be indefinitely banned from the profession for failing to use the preferred pronouns of a female student who identifies as a boy.

In May 2023, the Teaching Regulatory Authority ruled that Sutcliffe breached “professional conduct ethics” after praising a group of students during a maths lesson by stating, “Well done, girls.”

The student said Sutcliffe’s remark was targeted and deliberate, a claim supported by another teacher who alleged they had previously informed Sutcliffe of the student’s preferred pronouns.

In his judgment, Pepperall said that teachers must use compelled speech and “respect and celebrate the pupil’s personal autonomy,” regardless of the teacher’s religious or philosophical beliefs.

The ruling follows the Conservative government’s draft transgender guidance for schools published in December 2023, which suggests that teachers should not be forced to use preferred pronouns against their conscience.

However, the judge ruled that Sutcliffe’s conscience, based on his Christian beliefs, did not justify referring to a transgender student according to her biological sex.

“The draft guidance, which of course postdated these events and the panel’s decision, envisaged that schools would rarely agree to change a pupil’s pronouns but did not purport to suggest that such course would never be appropriate,” the judge said.

“As the draft made plain, such decisions are complex and are made by schools and not individually by each member of staff according to their own assessment of the merits of the request.”

The judge stated that Sutcliffe did not treat his pupil with “dignity and respect” because she “passed as a male and was known by male pronouns” at the school.

Sutcliffe responded to the ruling, describing himself as a “marked man.”

“I still stand by my Christian convictions that it is harmful and detrimental to affirm gender confused children. This is the belief I am fighting for which is shared by not only Christians but many who do not believe in harmful transgender ideology.  

“I have been a marked man ever since I dared to express my Christian beliefs in a school and tell the media about how I was punished for doing so,” he said.

Sutcliffe went on to say, “I refuse to go against my Christian faith and conscience and cause a child harm. I refuse to apologise for that. I do not believe it is any child’s best interest to affirm them in something that is untrue.”

Andrea Williams, chief executive of the Christian Legal Centre, said: “At the Christian Legal Centre we lived this case in real-time alongside Joshua. The way Mr Justice Pepperall describes Joshua in his judgment reads like fiction.

“The picture Mr Justice Pepperall paints of Joshua and his beliefs is a far cry from the caring, kind and brilliant maths teacher we know Joshua to be.

“We create a turbulent environment in schools when facts are turned on their head against the teacher in a context where children are identifying as the opposite sex. Teachers are treading on eggshells for fear of saying the wrong thing.

“The teaching profession is not a safe place to navigate for Christian teachers. Expressing long-held Christian beliefs on marriage and gender can get you suspended, investigated and barred.

“We are looking at the judgment carefully. We will continue to support Joshua for as long as it takes to secure justice.”

Special Request:

For nearly eight years, we've highlighted issues ignored by mainstream media and resisted globalist ideologies eroding Western civilization. We've done this joyfully, without paywalls, despite personal costs to our team. Your support has kept us going, but operating costs exceed donations, forcing us to use ads. We’d love to ditch them, so we’re asking for your help. If you value our work, please consider supporting us via Stripe or PayPal. Every bit helps us keep fighting for our kids’ future. Thank you!

What's New?

Use the blue arrows at the bottom to scroll through the latest.
There’s No Such Thing as a Religiously Neutral Society

There’s No Such Thing as a Religiously Neutral Society

"Absolute freedom is only possible in a lawless society. So, whether it is secularism or Christianity taking precedence, every alternative will be restrained at the point in which it conflicts with what the reigning system deems “good” for the wider society."
By
by Ben DavisApr 8, 2025
Is Christianity Jewish?

Is Christianity Jewish?

"The Church is neither Jewish nor Gentile, it is a new race, the third race."
By
by Matthew LittlefieldApr 8, 2025
Musk Warns Immigration Threatens National Identity: “A Country Is Its People”

Musk Warns Immigration Threatens National Identity: “A Country Is Its People”

"A country is its people. This is a fundamental concept that is truly obvious," Musk said.
By
by Staff WriterApr 7, 2025
The USA vs. The West: A Must-Read Viral Post by Martyn Iles

The USA vs. The West: A Must-Read Viral Post by Martyn Iles

"'Oh, the Americans and their guns!' we say, in our smug way. Yes, they have a warrior culture. We do not. We don't have to, because we're a leech on theirs."
By
by Staff WriterApr 6, 2025
LGBTQA Apostasy Laws

LGBTQA Apostasy Laws

"While the government promotes initiatives to encourage people to 'come out,' it simultaneously threatens criminal penalties against those who would even pray with someone seeking to step away from that identity."
By
by Ben DavisApr 5, 2025
Australians Could Face Up to Five Years in Jail for Praying

Australians Could Face Up to Five Years in Jail for Praying

"The new law makes it illegal to engage in prayer or counselling intended to change or suppress a person’s sexuality or gender identity—even if that person requests it..."
By
by Ben DavisApr 5, 2025
Todd Komarnicki’s “Bonhoeffer: Pastor, Spy, Assassin” Doesn’t Disappoint

Todd Komarnicki’s “Bonhoeffer: Pastor, Spy, Assassin” Doesn’t Disappoint

Rod Lampard reviews Todd Komarnicki’s “Bonhoeffer: Pastor, Spy, Assassin”
By
by Rod LampardApr 5, 2025

Image

Support

If you value our work and would like to support us, you can do so by visiting our support page. Can’t find what you’re looking for? Visit our search page.

Copyright © 2025, Caldron Pool

Permissions

Everything published at Caldron Pool is protected by copyright and cannot be used and/or duplicated without prior written permission. Links and excerpts with full attribution are permitted. Published articles represent the opinions of the author and may not reflect the views of all contributors at Caldron Pool.

Caldron Pool does not condone the use of violence, threats, or intimidation for political or religious purposes. We strongly advocate for peaceful, respectful, and free communication and open debate without fear of reprisal or punishment.