Image

Christianity Today, where is the consistency?

If Christianity Today is to remain at the top of its game after their recent support for the full impeachment of Donald Trump, on what is already widely agreed to be manufactured political maneuvering by Leftists, they’ll now need to give voice to a broader theological critique. Australia’s Eternity News also seemingly plopped itself onto the bandwagon, defending what looked like its own giddy, veiled applause with the dismissal that “reporting the news is not the same as supporting the contents of it.” This is despite individuals calling the article “brave.” Readers of both Eternity News and Christianity Today would……

If Christianity Today is to remain at the top of its game after their recent support for the full impeachment of Donald Trump, on what is already widely agreed to be manufactured political maneuvering by Leftists, they’ll now need to give voice to a broader theological critique.

Australia’s Eternity News also seemingly plopped itself onto the bandwagon, defending what looked like its own giddy, veiled applause with the dismissal that “reporting the news is not the same as supporting the contents of it.” This is despite individuals calling the article “brave.”

Readers of both Eternity News and Christianity Today would be right to now feel a fresh entitlement to see from them a FULL Christian theological critique of the spirit of the age, if they are to remain consistent, including:

  1. Speaking out against abortion;
  2. Exposing the lies of deep state Democrats and career politicians;
  3. Providing a complete and rigorous defence of the rights of charities who graciously hold to a biological and biblical definition of marriage;
  4. Criticism of Islamic terrorism;
  5. Criticism of the abuse of women under Islamism;
  6. A blanket protest against the manipulation and mutilation of young people via transgenderism and the apocalyptic climate change propaganda;
  7. Condemnation of the bullying of Israel Folau, Margaret Court, and others under the guise of “LGBTQ rights.”

Given the trajectory, this all seems unlikely. As one commentator said, after reading about Christianity Today’s apologetic track record of Barack Obama, “don’t hold your breath, mate.”

Christianity Today’s treatment of Donald Trump and the previous President are miles apart. One simple search engine comparison proves it:

Screenshot of search results on Christianity Today for “Barack Obama”
Screenshot of search results on Christianity Today for “Donald Trump”

Why the concern? Franklin Littell, in analyzing the antebellum (pre-civil war) condition of the American churches, identified a pattern of ideological servitude. Churches across America, both North and South were internally divided along ideological grounds. Pastors preached a mix of politics and theology, subsuming the theological critique into the service of a louder ideological master. Thus, he said, was the precursor to the most devastating war the United States ever experienced.

How far Littlell’s analysis is to be viewed as a litmus test for us today remains an intriguing open question. Christianity Today has a right to voice their opinion, as we have a right to demand, and expect that this voice be a consistent one.

It’s in this demand for consistency; the necessity of a consistent Christian theological critique of all ideological strong-holds, that gives rise to a diverse, but united front, joined in understanding against all unnecessary division.

This may seem utopian, but the further people wake up to the Left’s own totalitarian sins while being fully conscious of the sins on the right, the more opportunity there is for the Church to boldly reflect light in an otherwise dark place. Thus perhaps avoiding what Littell identifies as an inevitable slide into a broader, all-out civil war.

Special Request:

For nearly eight years, we've highlighted issues ignored by mainstream media and resisted globalist ideologies eroding Western civilization. We've done this joyfully, without paywalls, despite personal costs to our team. Your support has kept us going, but operating costs exceed donations, forcing us to use ads. We’d love to ditch them, so we’re asking for your help. If you value our work, please consider supporting us via Stripe or PayPal. Every bit helps us keep fighting for our kids’ future. Thank you!

What's New?

Use the blue arrows at the bottom to scroll through the latest.
TruPlay CEO Blasts Google, TikTok for Censoring Christian Kids’ Content: “They Allow Pentagrams in Blood but Block Jesus”

TruPlay CEO Blasts Google, TikTok for Censoring Christian Kids’ Content: “They Allow Pentagrams in Blood but Block Jesus”

“The systematic suppression of Christian content—particularly family-friendly content designed for children—represents a serious threat to religious liberty in the digital age,” ACLJ concluded.
By
by Rod LampardFeb 14, 2026
UK: Over 71,000 Rapes Recorded in 2024; Charges Filed in Just 2.7% of Cases

UK: Over 71,000 Rapes Recorded in 2024; Charges Filed in Just 2.7% of Cases

"More than 14,000 sexual offence cases are currently awaiting trial in the UK. This includes a record number of adult rape cases — more than 4,000 — and nearly 2,000 child rape cases."
By
by Staff WriterFeb 13, 2026
Telegram Boss Calls Social Media Bans Weaponised Safetyism: “Once Freedom of Speech Is Gone, It’s Game Over”

Telegram Boss Calls Social Media Bans Weaponised Safetyism: “Once Freedom of Speech Is Gone, It’s Game Over”

“These aren’t safeguards; they’re steps toward total control.”
By
by Rod LampardFeb 12, 2026
Ruddick Slams NSW Parliament Motion on Far-Right Extremism as “Misguided or Malicious”

Ruddick Slams NSW Parliament Motion on Far-Right Extremism as “Misguided or Malicious”

"We are suffering a decay in social cohesion because we are being swamped by mass migration, creating a multicultural mess of distrust and identity politics," he said. “The vast majority of those people called far right are simply regular Australians who are dismayed at the direction this country is taking.”
By
by Staff WriterFeb 11, 2026
“Genocidal Language”: The Concerning Rise of Anti-White Rhetoric

“Genocidal Language”: The Concerning Rise of Anti-White Rhetoric

"We have the ability to take over this country," he said.
By
by Staff WriterFeb 10, 2026
50 Million Muslims Now Live in Europe, Up From 500,000 at Century’s Turn

50 Million Muslims Now Live in Europe, Up From 500,000 at Century’s Turn

“In a nation that was built around the Church of England, Muslims are now running major cities across the country for the first time in history.”
By
by Staff WriterFeb 9, 2026
NYC Mayor Urges Americans To Look to Islam and Muhammad

NYC Mayor Urges Americans To Look to Islam and Muhammad

"He said that while Islam can provide a 'moral compass,' government should supply material support and resources."
By
by Staff WriterFeb 7, 2026
Mike Johnson Tells Pope: ‘Borders Are Biblical’

Mike Johnson Tells Pope: ‘Borders Are Biblical’

"Despite the unfounded claims of the Left, supporting a strong national border is a very Christian thing to do," he said.
By
by Rod LampardFeb 7, 2026

Image

Support

If you value our work and would like to support us, you can do so by visiting our support page. Can’t find what you’re looking for? Visit our search page.

Copyright © 2025, Caldron Pool

Permissions

Everything published at Caldron Pool is protected by copyright and cannot be used and/or duplicated without prior written permission. Links and excerpts with full attribution are permitted. Published articles represent the opinions of the author and may not reflect the views of all contributors at Caldron Pool.

Caldron Pool does not condone the use of violence, threats, or intimidation for political or religious purposes. We strongly advocate for peaceful, respectful, and free communication and open debate without fear of reprisal or punishment.