Image

Ordinary people can’t be trusted with freedom, says former high court justice

Former High Court justice Kirby’s nasty and hostile opinion letter warns religious freedom will let people publish opinions which are… nasty and hostile. “Religious freedom bill ‘will sustain nastiness and hostility’, Michael Kirby warns”… or at least, that’s what the headline in The Guardian article warns. Allow me to interpret that for you. “The God-given social liberty to disagree, debate, articulate and act in accordance with individual convictions (a.k.a religious freedom) will sometimes be used by people who aren’t very happy and they may say some things a nicer person wouldn’t.” What former High Court justice Michael Kirby is really saying is……

Former High Court justice Kirby’s nasty and hostile opinion letter warns religious freedom will let people publish opinions which are… nasty and hostile.

“Religious freedom bill ‘will sustain nastiness and hostility’, Michael Kirby warns”… or at least, that’s what the headline in The Guardian article warns.

Allow me to interpret that for you.

“The God-given social liberty to disagree, debate, articulate and act in accordance with individual convictions (a.k.a religious freedom) will sometimes be used by people who aren’t very happy and they may say some things a nicer person wouldn’t.”

What former High Court justice Michael Kirby is really saying is he doesn’t trust citizens with freedom – liberal democracy – because they might use it ‘wrong’.

What is wrong?

That is precisely the question. Who gets to define what a wrong opinion or belief is? The government? Justices, judges, discrimination tribunals and lawyers? And once granted the power to censor opinions, can they be trusted implicitly to never abuse that power to entrench their own? No, of course not. Don’t be ridiculous.

Kirby’s ironic opinion letter to a law journal in which he takes several swings at Christians asserted the freedom principle of “the right to swing my arm ends when I hit another’s chin” is “being dismantled to give a free go to the religious arm swingers”.

No, it’s not. Not a single religious person wants the legal right to punch someone. That’s Antifa. Of course, Kirby is conflating objective harm (like a bruise) with a subjective claim of harm (like a bruised ego) resulting from robust debate.

The fight against religious freedom is the fight for a continuing and expanding inquisition into all who publicly dissent from the state’s mandated beliefs.

You may believe in God, but you must not believe He designed marriage.

You must believe unrepentant, practising homosexuals have nothing to repent of and go to Heaven.

You must believe biological sex is a myth and can be changed with a scalpel.

You must believe it’s a mother’s right to kill the children she’s conceived.

In the anointed elites’ vision of a radical secular state, you can theoretically believe anything, although that freedom has a few conditions. You mustn’t explain your beliefs to anybody, nor let your beliefs influence your public opinions or professional decisions in any meaningful way. If you feel you really must express your religious identity beyond the inches between your ears, you must contain such outbursts of unapproved beliefs to designated zones on the designated day (Sunday church).

It is the height of intellectual cowardice to pre-emptively censor one’s critics. That is the real objective of opponents of religious freedom protections. The socially-destructive loss of academic rigour and democratic debate yields only a temporary bliss from the resulting ignorance.

An illusion that all is ordered and as it should be is easy to achieve when all one has done is extinguish the light of religious freedom.

Special Request:

For nearly eight years, we've highlighted issues ignored by mainstream media and resisted globalist ideologies eroding Western civilization. We've done this joyfully, without paywalls, despite personal costs to our team. Your support has kept us going, but operating costs exceed donations, forcing us to use ads. We’d love to ditch them, so we’re asking for your help. If you value our work, please consider supporting us via Stripe or PayPal. Every bit helps us keep fighting for our kids’ future. Thank you!

What's New?

Use the blue arrows at the bottom to scroll through the latest.
Pete Hegseth Announces Monthly Prayer Meeting in the Pentagon

Pete Hegseth Announces Monthly Prayer Meeting in the Pentagon

"Hegseth told those gathered that the task of protecting the nation first begins on bended knees, recognising the providence of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ."
By
by Rod LampardMay 24, 2025
The Danger of Being Defined Only by What We Are Not

The Danger of Being Defined Only by What We Are Not

"Multiculturalism is an inherently reactive posture: we extend acceptance indiscriminately, only drawing boundaries retroactively, once harm is done or conflict arises and only ever at an individual level."
By
by Ben DavisMay 23, 2025
Officially Socialist?

Officially Socialist?

"So, the price of comfort is that we are treated like a cog in a machine. This becomes the ultimate sacrifice of our souls."
By
by Dr Stephen FysonMay 23, 2025
Disney’s ‘Lilo & Stitch’ Praised for Avoiding Woke Messaging

Disney’s ‘Lilo & Stitch’ Praised for Avoiding Woke Messaging

"Unlike some of the studio’s recent remakes, Lilo & Stitch appears to have avoided overt woke or ideological messaging—a decision that has resonated with many viewers, especially parents."
By
by Staff WriterMay 23, 2025
Trump’s Unflinching Mirror: South Africa’s Uncomfortable Truths

Trump’s Unflinching Mirror: South Africa’s Uncomfortable Truths

"Trump’s courage lies not in the precision of his terminology but in his willingness to broach this subject at all, knowing the denigration it would draw from a media that sees no fault in South Africa’s post-apartheid project."
By
by Michael MacConnellMay 22, 2025
Canada’s PM Promises to Punish Businesses That Reject Climate Agenda

Canada’s PM Promises to Punish Businesses That Reject Climate Agenda

"Those who are lagging behind and are still part of the problem will be punished," he said.
By
by Staff WriterMay 22, 2025
Trump Exposes South African Genocide During Ramaphosa Visit: “Watch This”

Trump Exposes South African Genocide During Ramaphosa Visit: “Watch This”

“We have thousands of stories talking about it," Trump said. "We have documentaries. We have news stories. I can show you a couple of things. It has to be responded to.”
By
by Staff WriterMay 22, 2025
AHPRA Targets Dr Jillian Spencer in Fresh Fight for Free Speech

AHPRA Targets Dr Jillian Spencer in Fresh Fight for Free Speech

"The persecution of doctors raising concerns about harm to children from gender interventions needs to stop," she said.
By
by Rod LampardMay 22, 2025

Image

Support

If you value our work and would like to support us, you can do so by visiting our support page. Can’t find what you’re looking for? Visit our search page.

Copyright © 2025, Caldron Pool

Permissions

Everything published at Caldron Pool is protected by copyright and cannot be used and/or duplicated without prior written permission. Links and excerpts with full attribution are permitted. Published articles represent the opinions of the author and may not reflect the views of all contributors at Caldron Pool.

Caldron Pool does not condone the use of violence, threats, or intimidation for political or religious purposes. We strongly advocate for peaceful, respectful, and free communication and open debate without fear of reprisal or punishment.