Image

Australia’s Media Elites Need to Stop Acting Like Pharisees

The recent High Court decision which unanimously (7-0) upheld the appeal of George Pell against the Victorian Court of Appeal’s decision proves—once-and-for-all-time—that the Catholic Cardinal is innocent. But that hasn’t stopped sections of the media from continuing to reaffirm Pell’s guilt. Advertisement Without doubt, the most shocking example came from Clementine Ford, whose tweet would almost certainly result in a defamation lawsuit if it were anyone else but a twenty-first century, Roman Catholic Cardinal: George Pell is a child abuser, a sexual predator and a life ruiner (sic). Apart from the children he personally harmed, he oversaw the harm of……

The recent High Court decision which unanimously (7-0) upheld the appeal of George Pell against the Victorian Court of Appeal’s decision proves—once-and-for-all-time—that the Catholic Cardinal is innocent. But that hasn’t stopped sections of the media from continuing to reaffirm Pell’s guilt.

Without doubt, the most shocking example came from Clementine Ford, whose tweet would almost certainly result in a defamation lawsuit if it were anyone else but a twenty-first century, Roman Catholic Cardinal:

George Pell is a child abuser, a sexual predator and a life ruiner (sic). Apart from the children he personally harmed, he oversaw the harm of countless others. If there’s a hell, he can rot in it. I don’t care what the High Court and his high profile pedo (sic) defending friends say.

Only slightly more restrained was Quentin Dempster, who tweeted:

Pell “innocent” headlines @australian. Also, His Holiness @Pontifex Australia’s uses the word innocent in a Tweet. This is a misrepresentation. High Court has determined that Pell’s guilt had not been established “beyond reasonable doubt”.

In a similar vein, Barrie Cassidy pontificated:

The High Court has found there was not enough evidence to convict. It did not find him innocent. You are then entitled to maintain your view and you are under no obligation to apologise for holding those views.

How can both Cassidy and Dempster—both ABC career journalists—know more than seven High Court judges? Even more seriously, is their total disregard of the central tenant of jurisprudence: i.e. that one is innocent until proven guilty. So much for democracy, the rule of law, or even the guise of neutral reporting.

Not to be outdone was the ever-predictable Philip Adams, who acerbically tweeted:

High Court finds jury guilty.

Then there was the last line of this hit-piece by Kathleen Ferguson—another ABC stalwart—which concludes as though Pell’s acquittal had never even occurred:

Cardinal Pell was the highest ranking Catholic official to be convicted of child sex abuse.

But to cap it all off was this op-ed by Malcolm Knox, a columnist for The Sydney Morning Herald, who inexplicably argued that, “There are 12 unmentioned victims in the Pell verdict: the jurors”. The result is of the recent High Court decision is that Knox believes:

…Appeal courts are going to be crammed. If higher courts can effectively retry cases and second-guess juries, if a legitimate ground for appeal is simply that the jury was “not rational” – not that a jury has made a catastrophic error, but simply that it was wrong – the system can get set for an avalanche of appeals.

But as the barrister Greg Barns, correctly pointed out:

This column is plain wrong. There will not be a flood of appeals. The @HCA [High Court of Australia] did no more than restate the law which is that if there is a reasonable hypothesis consistent with innocence you must acquit. Knox forgets that the evidence of defence witnesses was unchallenged.

It’s significant, and more than a little ironic, that over the Easter long weekend we stop to remember the wrongful conviction of someone who was, without a shadow of a doubt, the greatest religious figure in history.

But it was more than just a wrongful conviction, it was the greatest crime ever. For it was against some who claimed—and proved to be—the Son of God. A man who also had twelve people fail to uphold his innocence at his trial. And yet, was in the end, gloriously acquitted.

It’s a timely reminder that as human beings we all make mistakes. Even juries. That’s why we have a series of courts to ensure that decisions are reviewed so that justice can be done.

Don’t get me wrong. Cardinal Pell is not Christ. And as such he is not perfect as either a man or an archbishop. But Australia’s media elites need to stop acting like Pharisees. And in their zeal to see George Pell condemned they should stop and consider the words which Jesus said to the woman guilty of adultery.

 If any one of you is without sin, let him be the first to throw a stone… (John 8:7)

Even more, the message of Easter is that there is forgiveness for all. Those who are innocent as well as those who are guilty. Adultery might not be as socially unacceptable as it was just a few short years ago. But it is significant that Jesus refused to condemn someone who was actually guilty of it. Cardinal Pell, though, has been ruled to be innocent. But will the media, and especially those of the #love-is-love campaign, extend to him any mercy or grace?

Special Request:

For nearly eight years, we've highlighted issues ignored by mainstream media and resisted globalist ideologies eroding Western civilization. We've done this joyfully, without paywalls, despite personal costs to our team. Your support has kept us going, but operating costs exceed donations, forcing us to use ads. We’d love to ditch them, so we’re asking for your help. If you value our work, please consider supporting us via Stripe or PayPal. Every bit helps us keep fighting for our kids’ future. Thank you!

What's New?

Use the blue arrows at the bottom to scroll through the latest.
Europe Witnesses Surge in Anti-Christian Violence

Europe Witnesses Surge in Anti-Christian Violence

"A key report has revealed a sharp rise in crimes targeting Christians, documenting 2,444 incidents across 35 countries and highlighting escalating hostility against Christian communities."
By
by Staff WriterJul 12, 2025
Melbourne Royal Show Bans Annual Christian Exhibit, Sparking Religious Freedom Debate

Melbourne Royal Show Bans Annual Christian Exhibit, Sparking Religious Freedom Debate

“This is not just about one booth — it’s about ensuring that all Australians have the right to peacefully express their faith in public venues.”
By
by Rod LampardJul 11, 2025
We Don’t Need a “Hate Registry” Run by People Who Think the Bible Is “Hate”

We Don’t Need a “Hate Registry” Run by People Who Think the Bible Is “Hate”

"The concern isn’t whether people should have the 'freedom to hate their enemies.' The concern is that the same government already labelling basic Christian doctrine as 'hate' is now building a system to monitor, catalogue, and punish those guilty of heresy."
By
by Ben DavisJul 11, 2025
Race-Based “Antisemitism” Laws May Do More Harm Than Good

Race-Based “Antisemitism” Laws May Do More Harm Than Good

"Why not simply deport any foreigner who commits a crime against any Australian, regardless of their race? Why introduce a race-specific policy when the principle of equal protection under the law should be the standard in a free and just society?"
By
by Staff WriterJul 10, 2025
Finnish MP Battling Six-Year “Hate Speech” Case Considers Leaving Church Over Same-Sex Marriage Shift

Finnish MP Battling Six-Year “Hate Speech” Case Considers Leaving Church Over Same-Sex Marriage Shift

“Räsänen is still staring down the barrel of ‘hate speech’ LGBTQ+ lawfare, as her six-year court case over quoting Romans continues to be a frontline for free speech.”
By
by Rod LampardJul 10, 2025
Neutrality Is Surrender: The West Will Embrace Christianity or Die

Neutrality Is Surrender: The West Will Embrace Christianity or Die

"Christianity is the heart of the West. If that heart stops beating, if our faith dies, then our civilisation will not survive. It will be replaced by something else."
By
by Staff WriterJul 9, 2025
ACT Pushes Law Mandating Dog Owners Spend Three Hours a Day With Pets

ACT Pushes Law Mandating Dog Owners Spend Three Hours a Day With Pets

"How exactly will the government track whether dog owners are meeting the three-hour requirement? And who will monitor this?"
By
by Staff WriterJul 9, 2025
Victims of Communism Curriculum Mandated in Texas Schools

Victims of Communism Curriculum Mandated in Texas Schools

"SB 24’s requirements will give voice and visibility to Karl Marx’s often marginalized victims by offering kids ‘first-hand accounts, in-person, and video-recorded testimonies.’"
By
by Rod LampardJul 8, 2025

Image

Support

If you value our work and would like to support us, you can do so by visiting our support page. Can’t find what you’re looking for? Visit our search page.

Copyright © 2025, Caldron Pool

Permissions

Everything published at Caldron Pool is protected by copyright and cannot be used and/or duplicated without prior written permission. Links and excerpts with full attribution are permitted. Published articles represent the opinions of the author and may not reflect the views of all contributors at Caldron Pool.

Caldron Pool does not condone the use of violence, threats, or intimidation for political or religious purposes. We strongly advocate for peaceful, respectful, and free communication and open debate without fear of reprisal or punishment.