Image

Where Do We Get “Justice” From Without God?

"When the atheist appeals to concepts of 'justice' to argue against Christianity, he’s acting as a moral parasite. His argument is based on borrowed ethics that are incompatible with his own worldview."

­­Caldron Pool recently shared a short clip from Tucker Carlson during his speaking tour in Australia, in which he explained that Christianity is the only reason the world recognizes “human rights.”

The video has attracted more than 100,000 views on social media, and with it, the standard predictable criticisms.

Most seemed to agree with Tucker’s position, however, several claimed that the concept of “human rights” did not exclusively arise among Christians, but also emerged among, what they described as, “decent people” who believed in “fairness and justice.”

Others shared news stories in the replies of professed Christians being charged with heinous sex crimes, murder, injustices, and other forms of human rights abuses.

While we agree that professed Christians are still capable of acting unjustly and violating “human rights,” the question arises, particularly for the non-Christian: According to what standard? Where do we get “justice” and “decency” from in a godless universe? From where, exactly, does a transcendent standard that others are accused of violating originate?

Nobody ever really says in these sorts of debates. Concepts such as justice and human rights are all just presupposed. This is the baselessness and absurdity to which people are reduced by rejecting Christianity. If there is no God in the universe, then what are human beings except the unintentional chemical by-product of time and chance acting on matter?

What one chemical, or a collection of chemicals, does to other chemicals is morally irrelevant. Spilt milk cannot splatter “unjustly” or “unfairly.” So, what then are our actions except the result of atoms moving about in our brains in obedience to the fixed laws of chemistry?

Not only does the idea of godlessness do away with purpose and morality, it entirely obliterates the possibility of knowledge! In a godless universe, you don’t believe anything because it is true or good, but because that “thought” sensation is the present effect of a long line of previous, unavoidable causes triggered by the miraculous appearance of reality. In a godless universe, there is no transcendent measure of “true” and “false,” “right” and “wrong” to appeal to. It’s all chemistry, dictated by chemistry, producing the illusion of free thought.

Concepts of “justice” merely emerged within the brain of the individual. Where these conceptions conflict, individual to individual, there is no higher measure to validate whether one conception is more or less “just” than another. Justice is non-existent.

At this point, you might as well be talking about the “immorality” and “injustice” of preferring strawberry milkshakes over chocolate. That is all this debate ultimately amounts to if there is no higher written moral code that exists outside of our own sensations.

C.S. Lewis dealt with the problem of justice in his masterpiece, ‘Mere Christianity,’ when he argued that justice cannot exist if there is no objective, transcendent standard by which to judge actions and behaviours.

He explained:

“My argument against God was that the universe seemed so cruel and just. But how had I got this idea of just and unjust? A man does not call a line crooked unless he has some idea of a straight line. What was I comparing this universe with when I called it unjust?

“If the whole show was bad and senseless from A to Z, so to speak, why did I, who was supposed to be part of the show, find myself in such a violent reaction against it?…

“Of course, I could have given up my idea of justice by saying it was nothing but a private idea of my own. But if I did that, then my argument against God collapsed too—for the argument depends on saying the world was really unjust, not simply that it did not happen to please my fancies.

“Thus, in the very act of trying to prove that God did not exist—in other words, that my whole reality was senseless—I found I was forced to assume that one part of reality—namely, my idea of justice—was full of sense.

“If the whole universe had no meaning, we should never have found out that it has no meaning: just as, if there were no light in the universe and therefore no creatures with eyes, we should never have known it was dark. Dark would be without meaning.”

A godless universe is incompatible with any meaningful concept of “right” and “wrong.” It is for this reason that the idea of “human rights” emerged, and could only emerge, within a Christian context that presupposed the Bible to be true.

Man was only seen as having inherent value and inalienable rights because of the Biblical truth that all men are created in the image of God, and therefore, are owed a level of respect and dignity, regardless of their social status, beliefs, and ethnicity. No other system can coherently afford mankind that recognition.

This is why atheism is the religion of Satanic Globalism in its infancy. But it is only a means to an end. Its purpose is to undermine the authority of Christ until it can usurp the authority of Christ. Once that end is achieved, atheism begins to fade, and the concept of “God-given human rights” quickly dissolves into “state-granted privileges.”

When the atheist appeals to concepts of “justice,” especially when arguing against Christianity, he’s acting as a moral parasite. His argument is based on borrowed ethics that are incompatible with his own worldview. As such, the atheist must presuppose Christianity is true in order to accuse anyone of acting “unjustly,” and that, all while denying the necessary basis for any meaningful notion of justice to exist.

As Cornelius Van Til put it, he’s no better than the little child who is able to slap his father on the face only because he is held up by his father’s knee.

Special Request:

For nearly eight years, we've highlighted issues ignored by mainstream media and resisted globalist ideologies eroding Western civilization. We've done this joyfully, without paywalls, despite personal costs to our team. Your support has kept us going, but operating costs exceed donations, forcing us to use ads. We’d love to ditch them, so we’re asking for your help. If you value our work, please consider supporting us via Stripe or PayPal. Every bit helps us keep fighting for our kids’ future. Thank you!

What's New?

Use the blue arrows at the bottom to scroll through the latest.
Actor Zachery Levi Credits God for Faith-Fuelled Escape Out of Hollywood Hell

Actor Zachery Levi Credits God for Faith-Fuelled Escape Out of Hollywood Hell

“Hollywood had never been a healthy place for me,” he wrote. “I don’t know if it’s a healthy place for anyone.”
By
by Rod LampardNov 8, 2025
100-Year-Old WWII Veteran Says the Sacrifice “Wasn’t Worth the Result”

100-Year-Old WWII Veteran Says the Sacrifice “Wasn’t Worth the Result”

"Hundreds of my friends, and everyone else who gave their lives. For what? The country of today? No, I’m sorry, the sacrifice wasn’t worth the result we have now," he said.
By
by Staff WriterNov 8, 2025
You Watched As Young White Men Were Vilified — Now You’re Shocked You Don’t Have Their Respect?

You Watched As Young White Men Were Vilified — Now You’re Shocked You Don’t Have Their Respect?

Before you condemn these young men, ask yourself whether you’re really condemning the consequences of your own creation.
By
by Ben DavisNov 7, 2025
Why Modern Multiculturalism Dismantles the Civilization That Made It Possible

Why Modern Multiculturalism Dismantles the Civilization That Made It Possible

"Multiculturalism today is less about culture and more about religious and moral relativism: the belief that there is no ultimate truth, no objective or unchanging moral law to which we, as individuals or as a society, must conform."
By
by Ben DavisNov 7, 2025
Turkey Labels Christianity a Threat to National Security 

Turkey Labels Christianity a Threat to National Security 

"Up to 350 Christians have been booted out of the country since 2020."
By
by Rod LampardNov 6, 2025
Why Christians Should Be Wary of Another U.S. Military ‘Solution’

Why Christians Should Be Wary of Another U.S. Military ‘Solution’

“For Christians, the deeper issue is not merely whether intervention ‘works’ by secular metrics. It is the worldly temptation to impose our will on other countries through carnal, imperial means… The modern record shows that these ventures reliably make life worse at home and abroad.”
By
by J.B. RichardsNov 5, 2025
Vatican Declares ‘Co-Redemptrix’ an Inappropriate Title for Mary

Vatican Declares ‘Co-Redemptrix’ an Inappropriate Title for Mary

“The expression ‘co-redemptrix’ does not help extol Mary as the first and foremost collaborator in the work of redemption and grace, for it carries the risk of eclipsing the exclusive role of Jesus Christ,” the document said.
By
by Staff WriterNov 5, 2025
Petition to Stop Mass Immigration to Australia Nears 200,000 Signatures

Petition to Stop Mass Immigration to Australia Nears 200,000 Signatures

"This is not the country I remember and it’s not one I want to leave to future generations."
By
by Staff WriterNov 5, 2025

Image

Support

If you value our work and would like to support us, you can do so by visiting our support page. Can’t find what you’re looking for? Visit our search page.

Copyright © 2025, Caldron Pool

Permissions

Everything published at Caldron Pool is protected by copyright and cannot be used and/or duplicated without prior written permission. Links and excerpts with full attribution are permitted. Published articles represent the opinions of the author and may not reflect the views of all contributors at Caldron Pool.

Caldron Pool does not condone the use of violence, threats, or intimidation for political or religious purposes. We strongly advocate for peaceful, respectful, and free communication and open debate without fear of reprisal or punishment.