Image

Deeming Backs Smith After Pronoun Police Penalty: Refusing to Affirm a Lie Isn’t Dishonesty – It’s Courage!

“By supporting Kirralie, you’re really supporting every single Australian who wants to speak up in the future. This is especially so for women, because when one woman is punished for this, thousands of women are made silent.”

MP Moira Deeming is the latest big name to back Kirralie Smith. 

Deeming offered her full support for the Binary spokeswoman in an email sent to Binary supporters on Friday.

Signalling her solidarity with Smith, Deeming unpacked the road to pronoun perdition, stating, “Like any mum, Smith wants her kids to be safe and free to flourish.

“So, when she saw two biological males competing in a women’s soccer league, she spoke up.

“Kirralie posted online and referred to the two biological males as men, not women.

“For that, she was dragged before the courts and charged with vilification.”

This is an Aussie mum simply speaking truth, and for doing that she has had to endure “a years-long legal process that put massive pressure on her and her family,” Deeming added.

To this, Deeming exclaimed, and “I know what that’s like!” (see here and here).

“In the judgment, the court said Kirralie’s refusal to use the transgender person’s preferred pronouns was evidence that she was not acting in good faith.”

Apparently, “refusing to affirm a lie is proof you aren’t being honest!

“Can you believe it?” she asked.

Deeming went on to state that the $95,000 compensation penalty and the process of being dragged through the courts weren’t deserved. 

“Kirralie didn’t ask for this, but it’s happening, and you and I need to support her through it.” 

Doubling down, Deeming then asked supporters to donate and help fund an appeal (donate here).

Leaning on her own bitter experience, she remarked, “The legal process is long and expensive.

“And it’s especially punishing when you’re being dragged before tribunals and courts.

“By supporting Kirralie,” Moira concluded, “you’re really supporting every single Australian who wants to speak up in the future.”

This is especially so for women, “because when one woman is punished for this, thousands of women are made silent.”

Writing about her fines (compensation payouts) for misgendering, Kirralie Smith said, “She has been told to remove any posts or references to the two male players in female sport, and not to name them or refer to them in future posts.”

Smith must then do exactly that.

She has to “pin a post to all socials and the website, worded and ordered by the court, that names both of them.”

“How can I do both?” Smith asked.

The court is demanding that Smith do exactly what the court found her guilty of doing.

Speaking with Caldron Pool about the bizarre order, Smith quipped, “Make it make sense.”

Separately backing Smith, Binary, and Family First director, Lyle Shelton, also offered his full support.

He invited people to sign a ‘Back the Truth. Back Kirralie Smith,’ open letter in her defence.

The open letter, Shelton explained, is an invitation for people to take a stand on behalf of every Australian who’s been told by the pronoun police
“to sit down and shut up.”

This isn’t just a letter defending Smith, he implied, this is a protest on behalf of every Australian who doesn’t “believe someone born a man can “identify” as a woman.”

Signing the letter sends a strong message to activists.

By “saying no to activists, participants in the petition are saying no to the  erasure of women and yes to protecting truth, fairness, and our kids’ futures.”

The 121-word open letter is plain spoken and direct.

 “Enough is enough,” it reads.

“Speaking common sense truth shouldn’t land you before the courts.

“But that’s what happened to Aussie mum Kirralie Smith.

“She didn’t threaten or abuse anyone. She simply spoke the truth that biological males do not belong in women’s and girls’ sports.

“Kirralie only said what most Australians agree with. Yet she is being punished for it.”

As such, the letter declares, “I stand with Kirralie, and I stand with all those willing to speak the truth about biological reality.

“Kirralie isn’t backing down. So, I’m backing her.”

Join over 30,000 people who have already signed the petition by adding your name here.

You can additionally help by donating to Binary’s campaign for Kirralie’s appeal here.

Special Request:

For nearly eight years, we've highlighted issues ignored by mainstream media and resisted globalist ideologies eroding Western civilization. We've done this joyfully, without paywalls, despite personal costs to our team. Your support has kept us going, but operating costs exceed donations, forcing us to use ads. We’d love to ditch them, so we’re asking for your help. If you value our work, please consider supporting us via Stripe or PayPal. Every bit helps us keep fighting for our kids’ future. Thank you!

What's New?

Use the blue arrows at the bottom to scroll through the latest.
Australian Parliament Fast-Tracks Antisemitism Bill Amid Free Speech Concerns

Australian Parliament Fast-Tracks Antisemitism Bill Amid Free Speech Concerns

“History will not treat this bill well. This is a victory for the security state, the establishment, and the censorship industrial complex,” Senator Alex Antic warned.
By
by Staff WriterJan 21, 2026
Kathleen Kennedy Steps Down: Will Lucasfilm Recapture the Magic Without the DEI Drama?

Kathleen Kennedy Steps Down: Will Lucasfilm Recapture the Magic Without the DEI Drama?

“Although absent from Forbes’ list of Kennedy foibles, few incidents illustrate them as blatantly as the firing of conservative Gina Carano.”
By
by Rod LampardJan 20, 2026
Far From Over: 98% of Antisemitism Bill Still Stands, Freedom Advocates Issue Warning

Far From Over: 98% of Antisemitism Bill Still Stands, Freedom Advocates Issue Warning

"The Australian Government’s proposed antisemitism legislation remains largely unchanged, with only a small portion removed following public backlash."
By
by Staff WriterJan 19, 2026
Echoes of Eden

Echoes of Eden

"The enemies of Christ infiltrated the garden of Christendom and asked its heirs, 'Hath God said?' We ate. And today, we are suffering the consequences."
By
by Ben DavisJan 19, 2026
Final 130 Christian Children Freed After Month in Islamist Captivity in Nigeria

Final 130 Christian Children Freed After Month in Islamist Captivity in Nigeria

"Armed 'bandits' took 315 students and 12 staff members from Papiri’s St Mary's Catholic School captive in late November."
By
by Rod LampardJan 17, 2026
A Government That Won’t Acknowledge Christianity Can’t Defend the Nation

A Government That Won’t Acknowledge Christianity Can’t Defend the Nation

"By refusing to name its own moral foundations, the state undermines its ability to openly distinguish between belief systems that can coexist within its legal and moral order and those that fundamentally conflict with them. A society that cannot articulate its core moral commitments cannot coherently defend them."
By
by Staff WriterJan 16, 2026
Hate Speech Laws Are Just Blasphemy Laws

Hate Speech Laws Are Just Blasphemy Laws

"Blasphemy laws protect a society’s sacred object from verbal violation. Hate speech laws do the same, only the sacred object has changed. They are secularism’s answer to blasphemy law: enforcing reverence for the system’s ultimate values while denying that those values are religious at all."
By
by Staff WriterJan 15, 2026
Opposition Grows to Labor’s “Horrendous” Hate Speech Bill: “Worst Assault on Freedom Yet”

Opposition Grows to Labor’s “Horrendous” Hate Speech Bill: “Worst Assault on Freedom Yet”

Opposition to the federal government’s Combating Antisemitism, Hate and Extremism Bill 2026 is mounting across multiple parties, with MPs and senators warning that the rushed, broadly worded legislation threatens free speech, religious freedom and civil liberties while failing to address the causes of extremism.
By
by Staff WriterJan 15, 2026

Image

Support

If you value our work and would like to support us, you can do so by visiting our support page. Can’t find what you’re looking for? Visit our search page.

Copyright © 2025, Caldron Pool

Permissions

Everything published at Caldron Pool is protected by copyright and cannot be used and/or duplicated without prior written permission. Links and excerpts with full attribution are permitted. Published articles represent the opinions of the author and may not reflect the views of all contributors at Caldron Pool.

Caldron Pool does not condone the use of violence, threats, or intimidation for political or religious purposes. We strongly advocate for peaceful, respectful, and free communication and open debate without fear of reprisal or punishment.